archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Could someone HELP me - Faith

Could someone help me? I have been in a relationship with a guy for 3+ years, but now he wants to take a break in the relationship to see if I am the one. (So he says). This started three weeks ago ... and I am hurting. We have talked everyday for the past three weeks except for one day. Some of the talks were good some bad. We both call each other about the same amount. So its not just me....but now after three weeks he said that its not in his heart yet to come back and doesn't know if it will ever be there, but gives me hope that it might. He says he still loves me...he just needs this time for his freedom. He always uses the old adage it's not you it's me, and he tends to focus on some of the bad times in the relationship, however he sometimes throws in a good time. A little confusing huh. What should I do? Move on or wait....and is this normal. Please help I am really confused.

From: Bernd

This is all TOO common. We've been taught from an early age, by the examples all around us, that when we don't "feel" love, or the amount of love we think we should, there's something missing in the relationship. My guess is that, in general, both sexes have been conditioned from an early age in how they deal with the struggle over closeness and separateness in relationships: guys are terrified subconsciously of too much closeness, while girls are terrified subconsciously of abandonment. It sounds like both of you are right smack in the middle of those struggles.

The only thing that I've found helps in situations like this is talk, and a willingness to really listen, without trying to steer things our way. In talking, I don't necessarily mean talking just with him. Outside perspective can be very helpful, especially if you are able to talk with a relationship therapist (you alone, or with him if he's willing), and/or couples that seem to have a good relationship now, but have been thru the mill to get there. Their insights can be extremely helpful - they've likely covered a lot of the same ground that you're trying to find your way thru right now.

Ironically, his withdrawing IS about him, not you. Your panic is about you. Finding help and support to deal with that panic so it doesn't consume you every waking moment is something that YOU can focus on. The reality is that you have absolutely no control over what he decides to do. He may work thru his struggle, or he may not. Either way, if you interpret his decision as a measure of how worthy you are of his love, the fear you feel isn't going to leave, even though it might seem to if he "comes back". The more you search for insight that will help you put in perspective your feelings, and his, the better chance you'll give yourself of having the kind of relationship you deserve with him, or someone else in the future.

I wish experience wasn't so painful at times, but it is. My philosophy is, if I'm going to go thru that kind of pain, I want to gain enough insight to make it worthwhile - and even better, enough insight so that I don't have to go thru the same crap again in the future.

Good luck, and take care.

From: Mary

Bernd's comments are right on the money. I am experiencing much of what you are as well. The most important thing is, don't pull on him with tears alone, or with threats of any kind. If he comes back because of these things, you will never be able to trust that HE made the choice because HE wanted it. You must show him how you feel about him, what you value about him, and yes, go to therapy if you can. But give him that space. You are worth it.

From: Kristi

It sounds like he wants his freedom, but he wants to keep you too. He needs to realize that if this is what he really wants, you won't be sitting around waiting for him to decide. My guess is (the way it usually goes) that when he realizes you are also seeing others(even if your not), he will not like it so much. Sometimes we get comfortable in a relationship and think the other person loves us enough that they will wait. When we find out that that other person is attractive to others and we might just lose them to someone else, we tend to change our mind and realize what a catch we had in the first place. Hope it helps!

From: Faith

Kristi - You are so right.....I have an old friend from college coming into the area next weekend and I let him know that this friend called me to see if we could get together for a day that my friend is here. My boyfriend was very upset by this. And has started to make an effort to work it all out. He says that he wants to take it slowly to make sure that it is better than it was before and that we don't fall into a routine, which we kind of did. I said that it was up to us not to let that happen. Thank you so much for the words of advice, you were right on the money.

From: Been There Done That -J

I am only 19 years old, and I have been seeing a guy for almost 3 years. One night he decides that he needs his space, and suddenly I am thrown into a life of lonliness (all my friends went off to other colleges, our friendships disentegrated). With the help of new friends, I discovered that through the relationship, I had "lost myself." I became DEPENDENT on him for everything-love, laughter, happiness. My advice to you is to fully evaluate your life before holding on to the dream that your loved one will return. I did. I went out with other people, and I found myself. My boyfriend discovered that there was no one like me in the world. He came back to me three months later.....BEGGING. A word of warning though: It is possible that trusting each other again will be hard to do (if you take him back). My problem is that I keep holding on to the past, and the ways that he has hurt me. Well, I really just spilled my guts instead of helping you. Let me know how things turned out. I hope that I can help. Sincerely, -J

From: Faith

J - Sometimes it is really good to hear that you are not the only one going through or been through this. I really appriciate your thoughts. I am friend less because we have the same friends and they were mostly his to begin with. He just left my house....and not much has changed...except that he spent the night last night on some girls couch!!!!! I have to move on right now I guess, but it is so scarry....any thoughts on how you did it would be much appriciated. Thank you so much.

From: Faith

Kristie - Well .... I went away this weekend, and never called him and he didn't know the number. I left a message on my answering machine that he hopes I have a safe trip.......well when I got back I found out that he spent one of the nights on a nother girls couch......Well I know now that I have to move on...Thank You.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.