archive1997.gif (2218 bytes)
Questions, responses, & comments about relationships from past forum postings
Archives Index | 1997a Archive Index | Search | Add New Posting | Relweb Home

Loneliness - Clovis

I never thought I could get this way. for three years of my life, I spent all my time caring for an alcoholic/addict with severe issues of self-worth. I always felt better taking care of him than myself--I guess you could say that my life was taking care of his life and putting things in order, covering for him to his parents, helping him out with money and food--I didn't really have much for myself. And now he refuses to talk to me at all. I can't understand what I did wrong and he won't explain anything to me. It wouldn't be so bad except that this is almost a year later and I'm still obsessing about him and wanting to know what I did wrong. Can anybody offer advice?

From: Bernd

Run, don't walk, to your nearest Al-Anon meeting. Trying to understand an alcoholic/addict, and our own reactions to them, is too difficult for us to sort out on our own. The alcoholic is addicted to booze, and we are addicted to the alcoholic. They are both diseases - we didn't cause them, or want them, but we have them - and the 12 step program is essential "medicine" to help us learn to cope with the disease. Like having diabetes - if we don't get appropriate treatment, it makes our lives misrable, and eventually it kills us. Search for any help you can find on the web too, under codependency and living with alcoholism. You deserve more happiness than you're getting.

From: Damaged Shields

Basically, it looks as though you've answered your own question: You distracted yourself from your own life, and spent all your time taking care of someone else, which took away from your own life and your own healing and issues. As far as this person not wanting anything to do with you anymore, maybe it's because they aren't ready to 'heal', or they don't want any help yet in their life. And being with you would only make them have to look at themselves, which is something they're not ready for. A person can't begin to heal until they are ready, and willing. If you read your post again, you'll see that you have answered your own question. I'm not a total expert, but I have had enough things that are similar to your situation, in my life, to where I feel I have a comment to offer. After I realized that I too was trying to fix everyone else, I finally realized that my time alone could be used for healing myself, and learning all the wonderful things there were to know about myself. Time alone now, to me, is very precious. And it's really not such a scary thing to look inside of yourself and see who is really there. Once I stopped running away from myself, I realized that I was missing out on the best friend I could ever have and be, and that was my relationship with myself. Now when I'm ready to share a life with someone, it's just that, to SHARE, and walk hand in hand. It's hard to walk through life with someone when one of them is sitting on your shoulders all the time. Go back a few posts and read my "When I'm on my own...." post if you'd like.

From: Clovis

I need closure. I don't know how to get it. Aaron's (my chemically dependent ex) refusal to talk with me does not give me closure. it makes me think that he wants to talk to me, he needs to talk to me, but he is afraid. and when he is afraid he makes stupid choices. so instead of focusing on my impending graduation and all the work that goes along with it, I spend my free time worrying about what he is going through. I still can't get away from this mother image I project to troubled men. my new boyfriend is also very emotionally needy, but has no alcohol/drug dependencies. why do I attract these people? for the most part, I am a confident individual. I work hard, I study hard, and I like to make people laugh, but for some reason confident men are not attracted to me. I feel like I'm doing something wrong. it seems the worse off a man is emotionally, financially, etc., the more I need to be with him because he needs me to take care of him and provide for him. also, I feel bad when I want to break things off or move on. why am I like this?

From: Oregon

Hi Clovis:

We all want to feel needed and important, and it seems to me the more troubled a person is, the more we feel needed. But if you read my message, you'll see the long term resentment and eventual collapse that seems to breed. People are naturally selfish and independent at the very very core, anything beyond that is what makes us human, but I believe that's where our instincts lie. My ex, in a sense, gave her whole day-to-day life to me and then wanted it back in a dramatic way. (I did most of the day-to-day tasks, and the kinds of normally adult individual responsibilities and planning that couples should share, I did FOR her)..... Although I resent her deeply for not meeting me half way and simply asking for the space she suddenly needed, I understand that she felt part of her was gone, and in my control completely. I've learned one thing from my experience--there's a point where you're not getting your (hopefully well-considered) needs and expectations met, and if it isn't worked out that that point, it goes deep into the relationship and festers. Highly Needy people just need, and they need from those who happen to be nearby...simplified of course, but it means that you may be somewhat generic to them.

This is the whole world of co-dependency I'm just learning about...but ask yourself what themes of your childhood appear in these relationships....maybe feeling like you matter, or are indispensable. Perhaps your parents made you feel somewhat insignificant...somewhere in you is an instinct to get away from this (hence you do sometimes break these things off) that's good--I didn't get away from what wasn't working and from excessive caretaking and now I'm paying a pretty high price...but I wonder why you want to "close" so much with this ex? A feeling I have too (though 8 years is a bit different) but also maybe the supreme caretaking act. You don't have to be thoughtless, but if this person doesn't want to talk to you, are you comforting your own sense of guilt by insisting they do? just some incomplete thoughts but maybe from a place you might find yourself in years to come if not careful!!

From: Bernd

Hi Clovis,

It IS really tough. Big soft hugs. You asked “why do I attract these people?”. Maybe a more helpful question would be “why am I attracted to these people?”. In relationships, my guess is that we tend to give out what we want back in return. If we want someone to help us with our inner pain and turmoil, especially if we feel that few people will do that for us, we tend to look for someone who is looking for much of the same thing. If we give it to them, then we can get it BACK from them.

We’re good at tricking ourselves into believing that we don’t “expect” anything back. But I think that deep down, we desperately crave that empathy and soothing for our inner pain. At the beginning stages of a relationship, the trade usually works fairly well, and we feel very much in love. But time begins to unravel the “equality” of the hidden trading; our partner doesn’t give us what we need or expect at times, and we feel resentful - and pull back on what we give THEM (unconsciously) - and THEY get resentful. Often, the resentments begin as small ones, but each one is collected, and pretty soon the bag of resentments each one carries gets bigger and heavier. Things tend to go downhill pretty rapidly from there.

You are “like this” because it’s likely that you learned well from the examples around you as a child, and also it’s likely that you got hurt emotionally a lot as a child, and found that it wasn’t safe to ask for empathy, consolation, hugs, and love when you were hurting. Often, to survive emotionally, we trick ourselves as children into believing that we’re tough enough to make it on our own WITHOUT anyone else’s help. We develop a shell of confidence, that helps us cope with life without feeling suicidal - until we get into an intimate relationship with someone who puts a horrific crack in that shell. We feel the painful, lonely emptiness inside that shell, and it terrifies the hell out of us. We will do almost anything, ANYTHING, to plaster that crack shut again, to hide that emptiness and loneliness - and often in our panic, we jump into an even WORSE relationship.

Clovis, that emptiness - that space inside your inner shell - NEEDS healing. That shell helped you survive as a child, but like a caterpillar in a cocoon, you can only fly free by letting it go. There is no other way. Every resource I’ve used to help me let go of my shell - and I’m still very much in the process of letting it go - can help you find the same freedom, and the same healing. The empty space exists for a reason - it is waiting to be filled with love, happiness, inner joy and peace, and all the other good things you’ve been wanting inside you all your life. Some days I can only add a tiny drop of those inside my emptiness, but other days it just seems to come rushing in. It doesn’t matter how fast it happens. ll I know now is I want to keep filling it, whatever time it takes.

Use whatever you can find. Search wherever you can. The biblical saying “seek and you shall find” has a lot of truth to it. You deserve love - and you especially deserve to get it from yourself.

Start with one step, any step. The rest will follow.

You may or may not get closure from your ex. That’s beyond your control. The more you can focus on healing you, and the pain from your past, the less you’ll need relief from your anguish from your ex.


The opinions expressed in any responses above are opinions only, and should not be taken as therapeutic
advice or counselling. For professional help with any problem, contact a trained therapist, or an appropriate
12 step or other support organization.
All contents Copyright Relationshipweb.com. Postings may be downloaded for personal or non-commercial use.